CW Trust Contracts For 61 Brandy Station Acres;
Must Raise $3.6 Million
By Scott C. Boyd
(February/March 2013 Civil War News)
|From the western slope Brandy Station historian Clark B. "Bud" Hall points to the crest of the southern end of Fleetwood Hill that the Civil War Trust is buying. The current owner’s house is on the hill. C.S. Maj. Gen. J.E.B. Stuart's headquarters was just over the crest on top of the eastern slope, near the house. Flat Run is in the foreground by the trees. (Scott C. Boyd)
BRANDY STATION, Va. – The Civil War Trust announced Dec. 20 it has a contract to buy 61 acres on historic Fleetwood Hill at Brandy Station for $3.6 million. The Trust has until June 7 to raise the money and close the sale, two days before the battle’s sesquicentennial.
The land at the crest of the southern end of Fleetwood Hill is the “crown jewel” of the Brandy Station battlefield, according to battle historian and Brandy Station Foundation co-founder Clark B. “Bud” Hall. It includes the site of Confederate commanding general J.E.B. Stuart’s headquarters for the battle.
“Protection of this property at the epicenter of the Brandy Station battlefield has been a goal of the preservation community for more than three decades,” said Trust President James Lighthizer in announcing the contract.
The Trust owns 878 acres of the Brandy Station Battlefield that are open to the public with signage, walking trails and a driving tour.
Unlike most Trust land purchases, this recent one became public before the Trust board had officially voted to approve the deal.
“Typically we wait until the board approves a transaction,” said Trust Director of Policy and Communications Jim Campi. “However, the news of it being under contract was leaked to the Culpeper paper, so it came out sooner than anticipated.”
Campi said the Trust’s board will make a formal decision on the purchase at its March meeting.
The Trust hopes to raise the money through $1.6 million in government grants and $2 million from private donors, according to Campi. “We need everybody involved with this deal. It’s a big number in a tight economy,” he said.
The government grants will likely be a combination of federal money from the National Park Service’s American Battlefield Protection Program and funds from Virginia’s Department of Historic Resources, Campi said.
“The key is to raise $2 million in private sector money,” he said. “Bud Hall has taken the lead in helping us identify big donors to help us get to that $2 million goal.”
Campi said, “We are concerned about the big amount of money that needs to be raised in a short amount of time.”
While being confident that Trust members “are going to step up like they always have,” he said the Trust hopes a broader group will get involved as well.
“Any help we can get from the Civil War community would be appreciated,” Campi said.
“It’s a steep uphill climb to get that $3.6 million by the sesquicentennial anniversary. We’re committed to doing our best to get there.”
The Trust plans a Fleetwood Hill Appeal mass mailing in February or March to initiate the public fundraising campaign.
The Battle of Brandy Station on June 9, 1863, was the largest cavalry battle in the Civil War with 18,456 cavalry from both sides and an additional 3,000 Union infantry engaged. It was the opening phase of the Gettysburg Campaign, taking place just three weeks before the battle. In late July Confederates retreating from Gettysburg camped at Brandy Station.
“Fleetwood Hill is without question the most fought over, camped upon and marched over real estate in the entire United States,” Hall wrote in a monograph describing the Battle of Brandy Station and Fleetwood Hill’s role in the Union Army winter encampment of 1863-1864. The army left on May 4 for the Overland Campaign.
Hall said the hill was of strategic importance because artillery placed there controlled five important road junctions that converged in Brandy Station village three quarters of a mile away. And the Orange and Alexandria Railroad passed the southern base of the hill.
“Although it is most closely associated with the climactic fighting of June 9, 1863, there were, in fact, 21 separate military actions on Fleetwood Hill during the Civil War — far more than any other battle venue in this country,” Hall wrote.
Joseph Anthony “Tony” Troilo Jr., who has contracted to sell the 61 acres, said the land has been in his family for 40-45 years.
Preservationists last considered buying the property in 2002, but were unsuccessful. Hall, who participated in those negotiations with Lighthizer, said Troilo asked $4.9 million, which “far exceeded our ability to acquire it, at the time.”
In the spring of 2011, Troilo dammed the perennial stream, Flat Run, without a federal permit, to create a pond on his property (see July 2011, January 2012 CWN).
Hall notified the Army Corps of Engineers about this violation of the Clean Water Act and Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. Subsequently Troilo agreed to remove the dam and restore the land and stream to their previous condition.
The Brandy Station Foundation’s (BSF) lack of action created a backlash against the BSF by some in the preservation community.
BSF President Joseph W. McKinney recently said the foundation did not want an adversarial relationship with Troilo for strategic reasons.
“We wanted to maintain good relations. The main thing I wanted to ensure was that if they came to a decision to sell, that they would be amenable to selling to preservationists,” he said.
The current deal began when Troilo and his wife put the property up for sale in late November 2011.
The controversy earlier that year over the pond was a factor in Troilo’s decision to sell. Troilo said, “No doubt, I’m sure it had some significance.”
McKinney said he was the first person Troilo told about selling and he notified the Civil War Trust.
The 2012 negotiation of the sales contract was conducted by Trust officials and Troilo.
A new appraisal, upon which the current deal was based, set the value of the 61 acres, including two houses, a pool, tennis court and other outbuildings, at $3.55 million. The Trust offered Troilo $3.6 million, which he accepted.
“It really makes sense for the Civil War Trust and Brandy Station Foundation to own that property because of the significance of the battle,” he said.
“That would put all the pieces of the puzzle together, and they would actually own what they tried to fight for 150 years ago.”
Said Hall about the pending purchase, “I could not possibly be more excited.”
Donations to the Fleetwood Hill Appeal and information about the battlefield can be found at the Trust’s website: